i so enjoyed reading everyone's comments and ideas about christmas gift giving and what to do- a great discussion. i agreed with every single point of view- and since those views varied tremendously, i remained unsure!
the real crux of the problem was that she already has a few doll houses- handmade, wood, thrifted, etc. all cheap or handed down, all awesome. she honestly plays with them all and loves to have friends over and they each use a house. if she just needed any doll house, that wouldn't be near as debate worthy to me...the real problem in my mind is that she wants this house just because it's the cool thing to get this year and all the cost gouging and fighting for the "hot" toy because of effective child advertising is really disgusting to me.
so as i went through my day's work yesterday i thought a lot and tried to decide my feelings about gift giving and christmas in general and come to a decision. here was the day's thought process:
1. it doesn't matter why she wants it, to her it's important. like the year i got a cabbage patch. i wasn't even sure why i wanted it, but when i actually got one it was magic!
2. we celebrate christ every day in our home, not just in this season. i know she knows the real meaning of christmas. the actual christmas celebration, to me, is as much about tradition and family fun and the world being a more happy and kind place for a little while as it is religious devotion. (but it is about religious devotion, like the whole of our lives). so i don't think it's wrong to enjoy the few years we have with little children who still believe in the magic of it all by making a wish come true- it is not our usual way of life. it's a special time. of course there may be years when that is not possible, and that's ok, too.
3. i think getting a fake or handmade version of what you really wanted is more disappointing than getting something else entirely. (i have a lot of personal experience with this one- others may feel different, but i secretly cried many times).
4. she's not a spoiled kid, and we buy most things from thrift stores. she knows that she only gets new toys on special holidays, and she actively helps me donate items to thrift stores/ humanitarian causes and happily pays her tithes on her tooth fairy money, you know?
5. ok, so then, i am not opposed to buying her the toy- but i am opposed to paying many times what it's worth to price gougers. she may have to get something else because i waited too long and didn't know its popularity.
6. and she'd live. but cate, like her mother, is all about expectations. if she is prepared she can handle anything. if she has an idea about what it will be like, she will love it no matter what.
6. so then a win-win would be to persuade her to love something else before hand. i'm good at persuasion.
7. so i decide to have the elf convo with her and see what other toys we come up with:
me: cate! i just saw on the news that so many girls asked for the barbie house that santa asked if there were a few brave girls who could send him a new letter asking for something else to help his elves out!
cate (eyes dreamy and fists clenched and on tippy toes): oooooooooo! that's going to make it so much more exciting when i get one!!!
8. crap. we talk all afternoon about presents, ideas, etc. and finally i convince her of a few things she'd like just about as much. she says ya, ok, those other things would be good, but i do still hope i'm one of the girls that santa can bring it to. decide that's a good attitude and she's getting something else.
9. get emails from awesome ladies this morning declaring that toys r us had just gotten the dream townhouse in stock again and it was on sale plus free shipping!
10. without thinking, purchase dream house as fast as i could type. it sold out five minutes later...
11. smile at my dramatics over this silly problem. get excited about the christmas miracle that just occurred!
12. vow to take my family to work at the soup kitchen one night, help cate clean out her toys to donate a few things to make room for the new christmas toys, and help her wrap a few things for toys for tots. vow to enjoy with all my heart seeing her face when she sees the barbie dream townhouse in front of the tree on christmas morning.
13. realize that i only have one child and i'm still a young and not wise mother; i'm sure i'm making a thousand mistakes (not just about this) and i know i'm always overly dramatic about every little decision.
but i followed my heart.... and that will have to do.